Instead of picking mid-cap stocks on your own, an index fund or ETF is a great way to buy a portfolio of stocks that is likely to beat the market average over the long haul. Mid-cap blend funds have historically produced higher returns than large-cap funds due to the fact that mid caps have more room for growth, and are generally attractively sized for acquisitions by large-cap companies.
These three mid-cap blend ETFs below offer wide diversification at a low cost, making them the best choices on the market today.
Why invest in mid-cap stocks
Though definitions vary, mid-cap stocks are generally recognized as those with a market capitalization, or stock market value, between $2 billion and $10 billion. In the most recent 15-year period, mid-cap stocks generated annualized returns that were more than 2 percentage points higher than a portfolio of large caps, helped by the fact that mid-cap businesses typically have more room for earnings growth than larger, established companies.
Outperformance from this segment of the market isn't purely driven by the strength of smaller stocks when stock prices are rising, however. History shows that mid-cap-sized businesses have proven to be more resilient in downturns. A paper by Hennessy Funds explains that in the two most recent recessions in the United States, mid-cap companies saw their earnings fall by a substantially smaller degree than small- and large-cap companies.
Below is the peak-to-trough decline in earnings during the last two recessions:
With this in mind, let's explore three of the best mid-cap blend ETFs on the market today, with a goal of finding the best mid-cap ETF to balance the needs of your portfolio.
The mid-cap blend ETF cost leader
Charles Schwab has aggressively reduced stock commissions and expense ratios across its suite of exchange-traded funds, making its core ETFs the lowest-cost funds on the market today. Its low-cost mid-cap ETF tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Mid-Cap Total Stock Market Index, which selects stocks based solely on their market capitalization, or market value.
The index's methodology for selecting stocks is simple. First, stocks are ranked by market cap. The stocks that rank from 500 to 1,000 are included in the Dow Jones U.S. Mid-Cap Total Stock Market Index, which is used to create the Schwab U.S. Mid-Cap ETF.
The stocks that make the market cap cut are then market cap-weighted in the portfolio, thus the largest companies make up more of the index as a percentage of assets. The result is a portfolio that has an average market cap of $7 billion, making it perhaps the closest thing to a "true" mid-cap fund.
The upsides of this fund are wide diversification (it includes roughly 500 stocks at any given time) and its low expense ratio, which makes it the cheapest mid-cap blend ETF on the market.
The downside of this fund is that it has only a few years of history, compared to Vanguard and iShares' mid-cap blend ETFs, which have more than a decade of historical performance each. But this fund checks the boxes for having mid-cap stock exposure at an extraordinarily low price.
The larger side of mid-cap ETFs
The Vanguard Mid-Cap ETF offers an attractive mix of mid-cap stocks that are generally larger than those held in the other two ETFs on this list. The fund tracks the CRSP US Mid Cap Index, which selects stocks purely based on market capitalization. The index includes stocks that fall between the 70th and 85th percentile on market capitalization.
The index's methodology results in a fund that blurs the lines of mid- and large-cap stocks. The average stock in the Vanguard Mid-Cap ETF has a market cap of approximately $13 billion.
To illustrate just how large its biggest holdings are, consider that EA (NASDAQ: EA), its largest holding at the time of writing, is also in the S&P 500 Index, a large-cap stock index.
Its bias toward larger mid caps means that it is less likely to outperform the mid-cap crowd in bull markets, when smaller stocks generally perform best. Notably, the fund has ranked in the top 13% of mid-cap funds over the last five years and in the top 30% over the last 10 years. That outperformance is largely driven by a below-average expense ratio, given that the mid-cap category includes many actively managed mid-cap funds that carry higher fees.
The smallest of mid caps (and the best performance)
The iShares Core S&P Mid-Cap ETF has generated the best long-term performance of any mid-cap ETF on this list, in part because of its bias toward the smallest of mid-cap companies. The fund's average holding had a market cap of $4.8 billion, compared to $7 billion for Schwab's ETF, and $13 billion for Vanguard's fund.
This ETF tracks the S&P Mid Cap 400 Index, which employs a different methodology for stock selection than the two ETFs above. Rather than pick stocks by market cap alone, S&P indexes generally rely on a "selection committee," which is responsible for adding or removing stocks from the index. Some basic parameters apply -- stocks must fit a market cap size and have generated a profit over the last four quarters to be eligible. The index typically includes about 400 stocks at any given time.
The S&P Mid-Cap 400 index is generally seen as the mid-cap index, frequently referred to as a benchmark for actively managed mid-cap mutual funds. Thus, this is the index that most actively managed mid-cap funds try to beat, though few have after fees and expenses are taken into account. iShares Core S&P Mid-Cap ETF topped 85% or more competing mid-cap funds during the most recent five-, 10-, and 15-year periods.
Low fees make this an attractive choice among mid-cap blend ETFs, as it has one of the lowest fees of any S&P Mid-Cap 400 Index tracker. Competing funds by Vanguard and State Street, the Vanguard S&P Mid-Cap 400 ETF, and SPDR S&P MidCap 400 ETF, carry substantially higher fees, so this iShares' ETF remains the least expensive way to track the S&P Mid-Cap 400 Index.
Picking the best mid-cap blend ETF for your portfolio
Selecting a good mid-cap blend ETF isn't just about investing in the fund with the best historical performance. A mid-cap blend ETF should further diversify a portfolio by adding exposure to stocks that aren't part of a fund in your portfolio.
For example, investors who own an S&P 500 ETF for large-cap stock exposure can confidently invest in the iShares Core S&P Mid-Cap ETF, which tracks the S&P Mid-Cap 400 Index. As a rule, stocks cannot simultaneously be part of the S&P 500 and S&P Mid-Cap 400, thus the iShares Core S&P Mid-Cap ETF offers the ability to add 400 unique stocks to the roughly 500 stocks that make up an S&P 500 fund.
Likewise, the Vanguard Mid-Cap ETF fits well with the Vanguard Large-Cap ETF, both of which are based on CRSP indexes, and thus have minimal overlap. On the other hand, the Schwab U.S. Mid-Cap ETF is a tough fit, because the largest 250 holdings in the mid-cap ETF will overlap with the 250 smallest holdings of the Schwab U.S. Large-Cap ETF. For this reason, Schwab's ETF doesn't offer as much diversification when paired with its seemingly complementary large-cap ETF offering.
Realistically, though, any fund above could be a great pick, if only for the fact that each ETF has a huge cost advantage over the average actively managed stock fund. Data from the Investment Company Institute reveals that the average actively managed stock fund carried an expense ratio of 0.82% in 2016, nearly 12 times more than the costliest ETFs on this list. Lower expenses make it mathematically much more likely that these three funds will outperform the average mid-cap fund, after fees and expenses are taken into consideration.
10 stocks we like better than iShares S&P MidCap 400 IndexWhen investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*
David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now... and iShares S&P MidCap 400 Index wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.
Click here to learn about these picks!
*Stock Advisor returns as of June 5, 2017