These 3 Offshore Oil Stocks Are Up 19% or More Since March: Why It's Not Time to Buy

Less offshore drilling activity remains a problem for these companies. Image source: Getty images.

Continue Reading Below

Since the beginning of March, oil prices have increased nearly 40%, lifting share of offshore drillersENSCO PLC,Seadrill LtdandTransocean LTDalong the way:


There's no denying that higher oil prices are good for the offshore industry. However, short-term increases won't translate to improved prospects for offshore drillers anytime soon. And that means it's probably not time to buy shares of these companies just yet. Here's why.

Continue Reading Below

Operating results, backlogs continue to weaken

Even as oil prices have returned to near $50 recently, and a number of global supply interruptions seem likely to keep prices near or even above that level for the foreseeable future, the financial and operating results that offshore drillers reported this past quarter paint a picture of weakness. Here's a look at the financial results and contracted backlog for Seadrill, ENSCO, and Transocean last quarter:

Q1 2016 Q1 2015
Company Revenue Net income Backlog Revenue Net income Backlog*
Seadrill $891.0 $88.0 $4.3 $1,244.0 $448.0 $5.1
ENSCO $814.0 $175.3 $5.2 $1,163.9 $324.7 $5.8
Transocean** $1,341.0 $255.0 $14.6 $2,043.0 $398.0 $15.5

Revenue and net income in millions. Backlog in billions. *Backlog data is from most recent prior sequential reporting period, not year-ago quarter. **Transocean net income is adjusted based on non-cash asset writedowns from 2015 quarter. Data source: company filings.

As you can see, all three companies reported weaker financial performance across-the-board last quarter, which may seem obvious considering that first quarter oil prices were the lowest the world has seen in well over a decade. However, that wasn't the biggest driver behind the deteriorating performance for offshore drillers, but more of a symptom of the long-term impact of low prices: Oil producers aren't contracting for much new offshore work at all right now.

Offshore oil won't turn on a dime

One only has to look at the contracted backlogs reported by Seadrill, ENSCO, and Transocean last quarter to see this playing out. For well over a year now, contract backlogs at offshore drillers have gone backwards, as drillers continue to work through contracts they signed in prior years.Sure, there has been some new work awarded in recent months, as we saw from Seadrill's earnings report

As things stand today, most oil companies that contract with offshore drillers are still focused on cutting capital spending, and that's likely to continue through the end of 2016 at the very least. So far, there's been zero evidence that $50 oil is changing any minds on that. To the contrary, a recent moveStatoil ASA shows how averse drillers are to spending on oil and gas field development today.

Statoil still had Seadrill'sWest Herculesunder contract through the end of the year, but instead of putting the vessel to work in theAasta Hansteen gas field off the Canadian coast as it had been planning, the company instead chose to cancel the remaining term with Seadrill and pay the company $61 million. Tonotdrill.

Not only will Statoil save about $33 million to terminate the contract early, but it will also defer tens of millions of other costs related to starting up the Aasta Hansteen field at a later date. With oil and gas prices still far below historical levels, it's likely that more producers will follow suit, putting off expensive offshore development simply to make ends meet this year.

Eventually offshore will recover, but it's unclear who the winners will be

There's no getting around the reality that the oil and gas reserves found offshore will be a necessary source of energy in the years and decades to come. But one only has to look at the boom and bust history of the industry to remember that it can be dangerous jumping into the wrong companies too quickly. Case in point? The 70-plus oil and gas producers which have filed for bankruptcy

Now I'm not predicting that Seadrill, ENSCO, or Transocean will end up bankrupt before the market recovers, but at things stand today, these companies are living on backlogs that won't last forever, and they all have substantial debt obligations that must be met as well. So what's an investor to do?

For now, I plan to stay on the sidelines, looking for evidence that producers are coming back to the offshore oil patch, and ready to spend to develop those resources. When they do, I'll be a buyer. But before then, I'm not willing to risk any more cash on an offshore driller that doesn't make it through the downturn. And as things stand today, it's just too early to tell who the winners -- and losers -- are going to be.

The article These 3 Offshore Oil Stocks Are Up 19% or More Since March: Why It's Not Time to Buy

Jason Hallfree for 30 daysconsidering a diverse range of insightsdisclosure policy