I like James Altucher. He's a sharp writer and a smart thinker. It's just those kinds of people -- people who know what they're talking about -- who deserve to be called out when they say something silly.
Altucher did a video with Business Insider this week pleading with young workers not to save in a 401(k).
Continue Reading Below
It is -- and I'm being gracious here -- one of the most misguided attempts at financial advice I've ever witnessed. It deserves a rebuttal.
Altucher begins the video:
Why? His rant begins:
Everyone who has a 401(k) can see exactly what's happening with their money. You can see exactly what funds you're investing in, and what individual securities those funds invest in. These disclosure requirements are legal obligations of the fund sponsor and the managers investing the money.
You might choose not to look, but the information is there. An investor's ignorance shouldn't be confused with an advisor's scam.
Altucher lobs another complaint:
You can take money out of a 401(k) without penalty starting at age 59-and-a-half. You can also roll 401(k) money into an IRA and use it for a down payment on a first home or for tuition without penalty.
A lot of companies also offer Roth 401(k) options, where you may be able to withdraw principal at any time without taxes or penalty.
According to the Census Bureau, 91.2% of Americans currently of working-age will turn 65 in less than 45 years.
There are no 401(k)s where someone does "whatever they want with your money."
All 401(k)s are heavily regulated by the Department of Labor and have to abide by strict investment standards under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974.
Part of those rules require that you, the worker, have control over how your money is invested. Here's how the Department of Labor puts it (emphasis mine):
A lot of companies still offer subpar investment choices, but check out this article on how to lobby your employer for a better 401(k). Someone at your company has a legal duty to provide choices that are in your best interest.
It's true: Mutual fund managers earn a salary.
You know who else takes a salary from the stuff you buy?
Plumbers, accountants, electricians, doctors, nurses, construction workers, shoe salesman, car mechanics, pilots, dentists, receptionists, gas station attendants, TV anchors, the guy behind the counter at the coffee shop, the lady who scans your groceries, me, and -- at some point in his life -- probably James Altucher.
Look, a lot of fund managers are overpaid. It's an injustice. But skipping a 401(k), the employer match, and decades of tax-deferred returns because they draw a salary is madness. The employer match, in many cases, offers a risk-free and immediate 100% return on any money contributed to a 401(k). A mutual fund manager's salary likely eats up a fraction of 1% annually.
Plus, fees have come way down in recent years. Here's a report by the Investment Company Institute:
What does Altucher say to do with your money instead of saving in a 401(k)?
Haha, OK. I shouldn't invest in a 401(k) because mutual fund managers take a salary. I'm sure the bankers where I have my checking account work for free?
His biggest beef is that people just don't make money in 401(k)s:
There's a reason they "won't really tell you" that: It's nonsense.
According to a study of 401(k) investors by Vanguard,"Five-year [2008-2013] participant total returns averaged 12.7% per year."
The average return from 2002 to 2007 was 9.5% per year.
Even from 2004 to 2009, which is one of the worst five-year periods the market has ever produced, the average 401(k) investor in Vanguard's study earned 2.8% annually.
This is Vanguard, the low-cost provider. But even if you subtract another percentage point from these returns to account for higher-fee providers, you won't get anywhere close to half a percent per year.
There's actually a good reason to think investors will do better in a 401(k) than in other investments.
The rules designed to make it difficult for people to take money out of a 401(k) until they're retired create good behavior, where investors leave their investments alone without jumping in and out of the market at the worst possible times. Automatic payroll deductions also help keep long-term investing on track.
Take this stat from Vanguard:
The majority of 401(k) investors dollar-cost average every month and never touch their investments again. That is fantastic. If you could recreate this behavior across the entire investment world, everyone would be rich.
Altucher has another problem with tax deferment:
What does it really mean? About a million freakin' dollars.
Save $10,000 a year in a 401(k) -- half from you and half from your employer -- and in 45 years (Altucher's preferred timeframe, here), the difference between taxable and tax-deferred at an 8% annual return is massive:
You can play around with the assumptions as you'd like with this calculator.
Here's his final takeaway:
Great advice! But you can do all of that and still invest in a 401(k). And virtually everyone should.
** James, are you reading this? Let's do a video together and duke this out in person! My email is email@example.com **
For more on this topic:
- The biggest retirement myth ever told
- An open letter to everyone under age 30
- What's wrong with finance
The article Terrible Advice I Hope Young People Ignore originally appeared on Fool.com.
Copyright 1995 - 2015 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.