It's Time to Double Down on Domino's Pizza Inc.

Even day-old pizza tastes good, but Domino's Pizza's performance is anything but warmed-up leftovers, despite the market's reaction to its first quarter earnings report. Image source: Domino's Pizza Investor Presentation (May 2016)

Domino's Pizza scared investors with its big year-over-year drop in domestic comparable sales growth, but now may be the time for the pizzeria to deliver major gains. Even with the slowdown, its domestic unit has built an enviable record of 20 consecutive quarters of sales growth, and when one looks at Domino's overseas performance, it's an incredible 89 straight quarters of expansion -- more than 22 years of ever higher comparable sales!

Make no mistake: Domino's first quarter numbers weren't pretty, and they were actually even worse than the headline numberssuggest, because it used an accelerated share repurchase program to buy back and retire stock, boosting per share earnings numbers. But the pizzeria is still growing, is still profitable, and has a sound plan to keep the momentum going.

Coincidence or correlation?

Let's get the ugly out of the way. Although those first quarter comps of 6.4% represented an 810 basis point drop from last year, comps have been on the way down since the first quarter of 2015. They're more in line with performance seen justbeforethe surgebutareactuallydouble the 20-year compsaverage. The meteoric growth that ended last year was the anomaly.

Image source: Domino's Pizza SEC filings

The first quarter comps shortfall also occurred during a period when the national burger chains were running heavily discounted promotions. Wendy's, McDonald's, and Burger King all offered bundled meal packages for $5 or less, deals thathit the earnings performance of Dunkin' Brands, Jack in the Box, and Bojangles. That pizza shops were also pinched is not surprising.

Papa John's International , for example, only saw domestic comps rise 1% in the period compared to a better than 8% jump last year,while Yum! Brands' Pizza Hut chain was up 3%,somewhat better than its flat performance in 2015.

McDonald's has since largely dropped its promotion, even if it still lingers on in some places, and Wendy's is now shaking it up a bit to offer some customization, suggesting the fixed meal deal may be losing some steam.

It's also noteworthy that Domino's comparable sales peaked just as it officially changed its name, dropping the word "pizza" since it is now more than just about pies. Sure, pizza is still front and center on its menu, but you can also get sandwiches, pasta, and chicken dishes, too.

That may be a strategic mistake, regardless of its menu's fullness, because consumers know and love Domino's for its pizza, and that's what's will draw customers to its stores. More importantly, pizza remains a growth industry.

Everybody loves pizza

According to a national study by Smart Flour Foods and the Center for Generational Kinetics, more than a third of Americans go out for pizza or purchase a frozen pie from a supermarket at least once a month, while a November survey from the market researchers at Mintel found that 86% of its respondents reported having pizza at least once in the past three months. Pizza is second only to chocolate as the go-to comfort food for Americans.

Domino's has 5,200 domestic stores in operation, more than 4,800 of which are franchisee-owned. Internationally, it has 7,330 locations, giving it a total of more than 12,500 stores, but only 7% of total revenue comes from its international store base. As the company opens more stores in foreign markets than at home, it has an opportunity to grow that figure.

Comparatively, Papa John'shas 4,900 stores in the U.S. and around the world, whilePizza Hut has some 16,000 stores globally. Yet according to the industry watchers at CHD Expert, Yum! Brands chain's 19% market share is barely ahead of Domino's at 16% (Little Caesar's and Papa John's follow at 12% and 9%, respectively).

Pizzeria	Market Cap	Forward P/E	1-Year Return	Dividend Yield
Domino's	$6.2 billion	25.5	12.9%	1.3%
Papa John's	$2.3 billion	22.8	(6.8%)	1.2%
Yum! Brands	$33.6 billion	19.7	(11.5%)	2.3%
Papa Murphy's	$134 million	20.0	(55.5%)	n/a

One Foolish way to look at it

Domino's will feel some labor cost pressures as states implement higher minimum wages, but besides New York, the pizzeria doesn't have any corporate restaurants in the states that have implemented the biggest wage rate hikes (California and Washington are the others). So, it will be somewhat insulated from the effects.

The pizza chain has also outpaced the competition in terms of technology, where its mobile ordering platform -- even by texting an emoji -- has won plaudits for its ease and simplicity. It's also partnered with Apple to make ordering through the Apple Watch a breeze, as well as with Amazon.com's voice-controlled Echo technology. Domino's estimates it has recorded $4.7 billion annually in global digital sales.

President and CEO Patrick Doyle has engendered a remarkable turnaround at Domino's, and despite the deflation its first quarter report caused to its stock price, the pizzeria is still a sound operation. Its two-year comp is over 20%, a feat it has never before achieved.

It may not be the cheapest stock, but there were some singular items this quarter that, while knocking it down a peg or two, don't undermine the story as a whole, and Domino's Pizza should be set to deliver piping-hot returns for investors going forward.

The article It's Time to Double Down on Domino's Pizza Inc. originally appeared on Fool.com.

Rich Duprey has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Amazon.com and Apple. The Motley Fool owns shares of Papa John's International and has the following options: long January 2018 $90 calls on Apple and short January 2018 $95 calls on Apple. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.