Why Transfer From Your Old to New 401(k) Plan?
Dear Dr. Don,
In this volatile market with its day-to-day major price swings, I need to roll over my previous 401(k) to my current employer's 401(k) program. What's the best way to do this rollover to avoid any big losses due to a falling market?
- Padma Portfolio
Great question. I'm assuming you're invested in a portfolio of mutual funds with your previous employer. You want to do a trustee-to-trustee transfer of these funds, where the money moves directly from your old plan to your new plan. This way, your previous employer isn't required to subject the funds to a mandatory 20% withholding tax. If they cut you a check, that would force you to come up with the withheld amount in order for the funds to remain fully invested in the new retirement plan.
The trustee-to-trustee transfer will be in cash, so the mutual funds held in the former employer's account will have to be sold. Open-ended mutual funds only trade at the net asset value of the funds at the end of the trading day. Closed-end mutual funds can trade at a discount or premium to the fund's net asset value and can trade like shares of stock during the trading day. It's far more likely you own open-ended funds in your 401(k). You should be able to log in to the online platform of your previous employer's 401(k) plan and request the exchange of your mutual fund shares for money market mutual fund shares. Choose a nice, conservative money market mutual fund such as a U.S. Treasury fund. Request the transfer toward the end of the U.S. trading day, prior to 4 p.m. Transfer requests placed after 4 p.m. Eastern time will trade the following day.
If you want to control when the shares are sold, then you can sell them yourself in the old plan by moving the money from the mutual fund to a money market mutual fund. Then, when you request the trustee-to-trustee transfer, you're getting out of a low-volatility investment and moving the money into your employer's plan. You can make the same type of decision in the new plan, where you invest the money in a money market mutual fund and then change the investment allocation to your desired allocation on a day you feel is opportunistic for the reallocation.
The conversion to cash has to happen before your previous employer can do the trustee-to-trustee transfer, so you're controlling the asset allocation but the employer controls the timing. There's no guarantee you won't miss a few up days in the market, but then again you were looking to protect against downside risk.
I'm not a huge fan of rolling old 401(k) plans over to the new employer's plan, but then again, I'd like to think I'm a pretty knowledgeable investor. You can gain a lot of flexibility in how the money is invested by transferring it into a traditional or Roth individual retirement account rollover and possibly save money in annual account administration fees and expenses, too.
Figure out why you want to move the money to the new employer's plan. Convenience is one reason. The investment alternatives are another. I'm not saying it's the wrong decision. I just want you to think through why you're making this decision to improve the odds it's the right decision for you.