GOP Tax-Cut Effort Enters Critical Phase in House, Senate -- Update

The Senate has devised a tax plan that would cut the corporate-tax rate to 20% starting in 2019, according to two Senate Republican aides and one GOP senator, one year later than proposed by the House and later than the Trump administration had hoped.

The details, which also include a full repeal of deductions for state and local taxes, according to Sen. David Perdue (R., Ga.), are starting to trickle out as the Republican effort to pass a $1.5 trillion tax cut and deliver President Donald Trump his first major legislative win entered a critical period Thursday. The House and the Senate are operating on parallel tracks to clear legislation over a series of hurdles.

Passage of legislation through the House Ways and Means Committee, followed by the unveiling of a Senate alternative, will move the debate beyond fights between the GOP and Democrats and into an arena marked by differences between Republicans in each chamber.

Senate Republicans were set to release a plan that diverges from the House version, which cuts individual- and corporate-tax rates and repeals the estate tax.

High-income households would get the biggest boost under the House plan, with the top 1% garnering 20.6% of the cut next year and almost half in 2027, according to the Tax Policy Center.

The cuts would be paid for in part by the elimination of various household deductions.

Senate Republicans were leaning toward preserving medical-expense deduction and the estate tax, which the House plan eliminates, and toward striking the deduction for property taxes, which the House plan cuts to $10,000 annually. Senate Republicans may eliminate the property tax deduction altogether along with other state and local tax deductions.

"You go down the path of trying to repeal the entire state and local tax in the Senate, then that is just not going to work," said Rep. Tom Reed (R., N.Y.), who fought to preserve the property-tax deduction in the House plan, in a preview of the intraparty battles.

The House picks up where it left off Wednesday, facing the problem of how to fill a $74 billion hole in the budget -- and beyond that, the emerging hesitation of more Republicans.

As of late morning on Thursday, Rep. Kevin Brady (R., Texas), the committee chairman, hadn't said what will be in an amendment to address the gap and other issues, when he will produce it or how much time Democrats will get to examine it. He did say, again, the committee would finish its work today.

A Wall Street Journal tally has identified at least nine House Republicans who are either against the House GOP plan or undecided. House Republicans can lose only 22 GOP votes during a floor vote planned for next week if they are to pass the legislation given that no Democrats are expected to support it.

On the Senate side, Republicans on the Senate Finance Committee huddled behind closed doors to learn details of what was in the tax legislation. The broader Senate Republican conference was to briefed at 11:30 a.m.

Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn (R., Texas) told reporters the Senate tax bill would likely come up for a floor vote the week after Thanksgiving.

Write to Siobhan Hughes at, Richard Rubin at and Kristina Peterson at

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

November 09, 2017 13:48 ET (18:48 GMT)