Will Marcato's Influence Be Bad for Buffalo Wild Wings?

MarketsMotley Fool

You won't be able to tell by walking into its restaurants just yet, but big changes are happening at Buffalo Wild Wings (NASDAQ: BWLD).

That's not to say this hasn't been brewing for some time. Activist investor firm and B-Dubs stakeholder Marcato Capital has been lobbying for Buffalo Wild Wings to improve operations and more effectively generate shareholder value for over a year now. But at Buffalo Wild Wings' annual investor meeting early this month, Marcato finally won enough shareholder votes to appoint three of the four representatives it nominated to B-Dubs' nine-member board of directors.

Continue Reading Below

The winds of (contentious) change

In conjunction with the results of the vote, Buffalo Wild Wings announced a "leadership succession plan" under which longtime CEO Sally Smith will retire by the end of the year, or until her successor is found -- something which Marcato has long argued would be in the best interests of investors.

But you can bet Smith isn't pleased with the arrangement. Only a few days before the vote, she penned a letter to shareholders insisting the company was already working to "address changing customer demands and sentiment," driving costs down, and implementing multiple initiatives to drive traffic and check sizes higher.

Smith also noted that the timing of her letter was no coincidence:

With that perspective, perhaps it's no surprise Smith opted to step down. But long before that, Buffalo Wild Wings had already issued multiple investor presentations and separate letters to shareholders over the past year, blasting Marcato's view of the business and its management.

Perhaps the most contentious among them was one just over a month ago, when Buffalo Wild Wings challenged what it called "Marcato's pattern of inaccurate and misleading statements," including its lack of operational suggestions to improve the business, its lack of a response to Buffalo Wild Wings' "detailed critique of Marcato's franchising related assumptions and modeling," and even the underwhelming track records of Marcato's board nominees for creating shareholder value at their previous jobs.

Moving forward

Yet here we are, with three of those nominees now formally part of Buffalo Wild Wings' board. And they're wasting no time exerting their influence.

Buffalo Wild Wings has since announced, for example, that it will pilot two new small-format locations dubbed "B-Dubs Express" in the Minneapolis metro market starting this summer. By implementing these locations with a streamlined format that focuses on take-out and delivery and has a smaller capacity for dine-in seating, Buffalo Wild Wings hopes to capitalize on consumers' increasing preference for more convenient dining options. To be fair, though, Smith herself hinted in the aforementioned letter that this was something Buffalo Wild Wings was already planning. It's unclear, however, whether those plans were pushed up as a result of the new board members.

More recently just last week -- and more relevant to Marcato's approach -- Buffalo Wild Wings also launched a company refranchising program identifying 83 company-owned locations for sale in Canada, Pennsylvania, South Texas, Washington D.C., and the Northeast U.S. region. Here again, however, Buffalo Wild Wings noted this was part of its "ongoing portfolio optimization process" with the help of restaurant and franchise investment banking firm The Cypress Group -- the hiring of which Smith announced during Buffalo Wild Wings' first-quarter 2017 report in April.

Of course, it's similarly unclear whether this large number of locations would be offered for sale were it not for Marcato's influence. But it does seem odd considering Buffalo Wild Wings has spent hundreds of millions of dollars in recent years to repurchase franchised locations and bring them back into the company-owned fold. In doing so at the time, Buffalo Wild Wings argued, among other benefits, it would give the company better control over its marketing, product rollouts, and dining experience.

In the end, Buffalo Wild Wings has little choice but to play nice with the new chorus of voices fighting to increase the value of its shares. And while we're all on the same side -- that is, aiming for the value of our investments to increase over the long term -- I'd be lying if I said I wasn't worried about the apparently conflicting views of the voices inside Buffalo Wild Wings' board room. But rest assured as a longtime investor, I'll be watching B-Dubs' progress closely.

10 stocks we like better than Buffalo Wild WingsWhen investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*

David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now... and Buffalo Wild Wings wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.

Click here to learn about these picks!

*Stock Advisor returns as of June 5, 2017

Steve Symington owns shares of Buffalo Wild Wings. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Buffalo Wild Wings. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.