Why Whole Foods' Future Is Smaller and Less Certain Than Ever

By Motley Fool StaffMarketsFool.com

In this segment from Market Foolery, Mac Greer is joined by Ron Gross and Jason Moser who weigh in on the growing uncertainty atWhole Foods Market(NASDAQ: WFM), which is apparently running up against the limits of U.S. consumers' willingness to pay a premium for natural and organic groceries.

The largest supermarket operator in the country, Kroger (NYSE: KR), looks like the long-term winner as most supermarkets now offer more and more of what once made Whole Foods unique.

Continue Reading Below

A full transcript follows the video.

10 stocks we like better than Whole Foods MarketWhen investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*

More From Fool.com

David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now... and Whole Foods Market wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.

Click here to learn about these picks!

*Stock Advisor returns as of February 6, 2017

This video was recorded on March 28, 2017.

Mac Greer:We wrap up with tough time forWhole Foods. According to areport fromBarclays,Whole Foods traffic has fallen by 14 millioncustomers over the last year andhalf. That's a 3% drop.I should add that Whole Foods co-founder and CEO John Mackey is on the board of directors of the Motley Fool. Jason,according to the report,Krogeris the big beneficiary. Nearly half ofKroger stores are within three miles of a Whole Foods.

Jason Moser:Yeah,it was pretty smart to do that, huh? I guessmaybe they felt like they were on to something. This goes back to what we've been talking about a lot in this space. Scale is really atremendous advantage. Having that big footprint,where you can get things from point A to point Bin the quickest fashion, and really carry a very wide selection of offerings, both private branded and brand names, isimmensely advantageous. I thinkwhat we always wondered with Whole Foods for a time was,would they be able to get rid of that Whole Paychecksmoniker that they had earned. It seemed likethey were doing a pretty good job of that. They were making that way toward offering more 365branded items, which certainly were more affordable. And I think that attracted more customers, for a time. But they really have run into a buzzsaw here in thatevery grocery store concept in the country is copying that model now, and bringing more and more naturals andorganics into their mix. Andfurthermore, we talked about this,Whole Foods doesn't really do a very good job ofattracting the crossover consumer. So, theydon't have a lot of what people really still want. Andthat's a big problem,because now you're telling meI have to go to more than one place to get everything.

Greer:Yeah,I don't want to do that.

Ron Gross:That was always, though. You wouldgo to a regular supermarket for your paper towelsand household items. Then, if you wanted organicsor really good produce or really good meat and fish, you would pop over to Whole Foods. Two trips. Kind of annoying. Now,Kroger's brand, Harris Teeter, you get a lot of that right there. Now,I do not think the quality of the produce in the meats are the same at Harris Teeter and Whole Foods. Whole Foods still does a better job. If I have a dinner party,I'm still going to Whole Foods. But on a regular, weekly basis, it becomes lessnecessary to go to Whole Foods,which is never good for a business model.


Greer:So,what does this mean if you're Whole Foods investor,or you're someone who's looking at the stock?

Gross:I am a Whole Foods investor,and I'm not that thrilled about it lately. Evenover the last five years,the stock is down around 30%. In my head, it was a more recent decline. But they've really been on the downturn for quite some time. I'm not a seller yet. To be honest,I'm not sure why I'm not. It'sbecause I like the experience,I'm a consumer and I shop there,and I'll continue to support it as a shareholder.

Greer:Andyou have lunch there a lot.

Gross:I have lunch there almost every day.[laughs]

Greer:So,they have their prepared foods,some of the stores have bars now, sothey have some built-in advantages, right?

Gross:They do. I remain a loyal customer, and therefore, for now,I remain a loyal shareholder as well.

Moser:I don't know.I'm not a Whole Foods investor. We did own shares of Whole Foods inMillion Dollar Portfolio,but we sold them a little while back.I think really, the icing on the cake for us wasin the most recent quarter, when they finally came to reality here in that they needed to pull back on what they saw as their full market opportunity. For a while, they were targeting 1,200 total stores around the country,which, we felt like, was too many. They, I think, now realize that that's too many. They pulled back on that guidance. They put that 365 store concept on hold to reasses which waythey want to go with it. Right now, they're talking about going back to their roots and really focusing on that core Whole Foods customer that helped get them to this point today. It's almost like saying they're going back to that Whole Paychecks moniker. They'regoing back to targeting that consumer. Honestly,that probably is their best bet. I think we'vecome to a point where we realize,Whole Foods isn't going to be able to growas much as a lot of people thought it was going to. So,maybe their best bet is to be that high-end grocer that focuses on a smaller overall market opportunity, but serves that market opportunity in an excellent fashion.

And if they do that, it can certainly still perform well, possibly even see margins getback to expanding if they're able to keep on raising those prices a little bit. Because,for the last few years, they really have been focusing on value, to the extent that you would get it even on the grocery bags. If you have your grocery bags fromWhole Foods you would see on the bags that they were talking about daily deals and value offerings and all this stuff. They weregetting down to having to compete on pricing withall of these other bigger competitors out there. Theycan't win that game. They're too small to do it. So, then you have to wonder, really, is the path to success heresome type of an acquisition? Do they need to acquire something like aPublix to grow that market opportunity and focus on a number of different tiers?Sprouts, a company thatjust went public shortly ago, acompetitor to Whole Foods, sounds like they may beacquired byAlbertsons, whichalso owns Safeway. So,you can certainly see consolidation in this sector. I think Whole Foods ismore than likely going to have to eithermake an acquisition of some sort, or they are really going to be focusing just on that whole paycheck customer, and accepting the fact that they can only become so big.

John Mackey, CEO of Whole Foods Market, is a member of The Motley Fool's board of directors. Jason Moser owns shares of Whole Foods Market. Mac Greer has no position in any stocks mentioned. Ron Gross owns shares of Whole Foods Market. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Whole Foods Market. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.