A lot has been made of the way business-to-consumer e-commerce demand is surging, and how package delivery companies like United Parcel Service and FedEx Corporation will benefit from it in the long term. However, it hasn't been smooth sailing for those shippers just yet. Volumes have increased strongly during recent holiday seasons, putting pressure on both companies as they attempt to deal with the demand. Consequently, both companies have taken costly measures to improve their abilities to cope with peak. Has peak demand affected profitability, particularly in the fourth quarter?
Troubles with peakA look at adjusted operating profit growth in the core U.S. domestic package segment -- which typically generates 60% to 65% of operating profits -- shows that growth has slowed in recent years.
Continue Reading Below
DATA SOURCE: UNITED PARCEL SERVICE PRESENTATIONS.
UPS has suffered two consecutive weak fourth quarters, as the company struggled to deal with severe winter conditions in 2013 -- FedEx also had issues -- then overinvested for 2014, and saw profits hit as it was left with excess capacity on certain days in the peak demand season. I've already looked at what FedEx and UPS are doing to deal with peak this year, and discussed one structural reason thatFedEx might be better suited to handle it.
Guidance implies flattish sequential growthAfter two difficult holiday seasons, UPS investors will be hoping no hiccups occur this year, but there are question marks around UPS' underlying profitability even if UPS executes as planned in the fourth quarter.
Indeed, the question came up on the recent third-quarter earnings call, when Wolfe Research analyst Scott Group asked whether "something has changed" with regard to the sequential improvement in earnings from the third to the fourth quarters.
His point was that management is predicting fourth-quarter operating profit growth in the U.S "in the low double-digits" -- a growth rate that implies flat sequential (third- to fourth-quarter) growth.
Adjusted operating profit growth for the U.S. domestic package segment in 2014's fourth quarter was $1.137 billion. Assuming the low double-digit growth talked about by UPS management works out to 12.5%, then this year's fourth quarter should produce $1.279 billion in adjusted operating profit for the segment -- only a 1.7% improvement on the third quarter of 2015, and $99 million less than generated in the fourth quarter of 2012.
As you can see in the chart below, sequential revenue growth (from the third to the fourth quarters) has increased, but in the last two years, adjusted operating profit growth has been weak, and the guidance for 2015 -- the 1.7% figure just calculated -- implies a slowdown from traditional sequential growth rates.
DATA SOURCE: UNITED PARCEL SERVICE PRESENTATIONS. AUTHOR'S ANALYSIS.
In response to Group's question, UPS CEO David Abney said, "[P]rior to this big growth in B2C e-commerce ... our average peak day was increasing volume, somewhere around 50% over a typical day. Now, with e-commerce, last year we approached 75% over." And, he noted, "the relationship between third and fourth quarter has just migrated a little bit just over this B2C growth."
Frankly, based on all of this, it looks like dealing with peak demand will be as much a challenge as an opportunity.
Three considerationsOn the other hand, there are certain considerations:
- Business-to-business, or B2B, is slowing in 2015, and this may have affected UPS' forecast for the fourth quarter.
- Lower fuel surcharges -- due to lower jet fuel prices -- have reduced revenue growth in 2015.
- The imposition of wide-scale dimensional-weight pricing -- under which the cost to ship a package is based on both its dimensions and weight, instead of weight alone -- has tended to constrain volume growth but increase prices, and could lead to more profit growth in future.
Indeed, adjusted operating profit in the U.S. domestic package segment grew 3.3% in the first nine months of 2015 compared to the same period last year -- despite slowing economic growth and lower fuel surcharges.
The takeawayAll told, as you can see in the second chart above, it seems that after three strong fourth quarters from 2010 to 2012 -- when UPS profited nicely from e-commerce growth during the holiday season -- the last two years were very difficult. This year's projected growth isn't looking stellar, either, even if the considerations above are kept in mind.
It's not that UPS doesn't have good growth prospects from e-commerce. After all, e-commerce deliveries are made all year round, and any business would want a pickup in end demand. However, it appears the Thanksgiving to Christmas period doesn't represent the huge growth opportunity for the company that it might have seemed to offer a few years ago.
The article Is E-Commerce Growth Actually Hurting United Parcel Service? originally appeared on Fool.com.
Lee Samaha has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends FedEx and United Parcel Service. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright 1995 - 2015 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.