How Much Will the Next Round of Tariffs Hurt Deep-Discount Shoppers?
Deep-discount retailers like Dollar General (NYSE: DG), Dollar Tree (NASDAQ: DLTR), and Five Below (NASDAQ: FIVE) have largely mitigated the impact of the escalating trade war between the U.S. and China through a number of strategies that precluded the need to raise prices.
But as the rift widens between the U.S. and its trading partners -- most notably China -- another round of tariff hikes on thousands of additional goods and products is being considered, and the deep discounters may no longer be able to work around the situation. Indeed, many already plan to raise prices, meaning consumers will pay the cost.
Resorting to Plan B
Retailers were prepared for the first tranche of tariffs increases that saw the duties on so-called List 3 items rise to 10% last year. The increase to 25% that was first scheduled for March, but delayed until May, caused more consternation for some, though others used the opportunity to adopt strategies that minimized the impact on consumers.
Dollar General CFO John Garratt told analysts the dollar store chain focused on four areas of mitigation: negotiating with vendors, product substitution, reengineering products, and seeking out different countries to source from. Previously, he said Dollar General bought extra inventory early to beat the tariffs.
Dollar Tree similarly pulled inventory forward, noting that had the tariff increases gone into effect as scheduled, it would have been a $100 million hit for the namesake chain for the full year and $40 million for its Family Dollar chain.
The first domino to fall
The situation was a bit different for Five Below, which fully mitigated the 10% tariff increase by pulling forward its spring inventory into 2018, but took a wait-and-see approach regarding the potential for the tariffs to rise 25%. While that paid off in the first quarter as the increase didn't go into effect until after the period ended, the chain is now hurrying to negotiate with vendors, change suppliers, and generate "process efficiencies." It also means it is going to raise prices.
CEO Joel Anderson told analysts it was "a decision we do not take lightly," but prices on items it sells for $1 would rise to $4, and those that it sells for $5 will be increased from there. About 40% of Five Below's merchandise is priced at $5, but Anderson stressed most of its products will remain below that threshold.
Fortunately it began implementing an experiment to sell a small selection of goods for $10 or less called 10 Below, though at the moment it's only in 25 stores (Dollar Tree is also experimenting with prices above $1).
Now with so-called List 4 items covering $300 billion worth of goods possibly seeing a tariff hike up to 25%, even the dollar stores are saying prices are going to go up.
A trickle turning into a torrent
Dollar General's Garratt told analysts last week: "We will do everything we can to minimize the impact of tariffs on our customers. But even with these efforts, we believe our shoppers will be facing higher prices as 2019 progresses."
Similarly, Dollar Tree's CEO Gary Philbin said, "If tariffs on List 4 products are implemented, we expect that it will be impactful to our business, and especially to consumers in general."
All three deep discounters have maintained their earnings outlook for the year, even with the tariff hikes, suggesting they believe the actions they're taking, including raising prices, won't affect their bottom line. But the customers may not be so lucky.
The least able will pay
Although they all have somewhat affluent customers shopping their stores, and Five Below more so than others, the dollar stores in particular are targeted toward lower income consumers. Dollar Tree may be most exposed.
When Family Dollar store locations are cross-checked with income data, the median income of the neighborhoods it is in is $43,474, compared with $55,333 for its sister Dollar Tree chain. It's why Philbin told analysts last year when discussing the threat of tariff hikes, "As I've told folks before, our customers often don't have that extra dollar."
The U.S. is on course to higher tariffs that even the deep-discount stores can't evade any longer, but it will be their customers -- many of whom cannot afford it -- who will pay the steepest penalty.
10 stocks we like better than Dollar Tree IncWhen investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has quadrupled the market.*
David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the ten best stocks for investors to buy right now... and Dollar Tree Inc wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.
*Stock Advisor returns as of March 1, 2019
Rich Duprey has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Five Below. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.