BJ's Restaurants Takes a Page Out of Buffalo Wild Wings' Playbook

When BJ's Restaurants Inc.(NASDAQ: BJRI)released fourth-quarter 2016 results late last month, shares climbed with good reason. The popular brewpub not only delivered a reasonably solid performance in spite of persistent dining industry headwinds, but also outlined a number of promising plans designed to boost sales in the coming quarters.

Interestingly, those plans are eerily similar to those already implemented by fellow casual-dining restaurant specialist Buffalo Wild Wings (NASDAQ: BWLD). But before we get to that, let's take a closer look at what BJ's has in store.

Image source: BJ's Restaurants.

"One of our strongest-ever sales initiative plans"

More specifically, BJ's outlined four major sales-driving initiatives, including:

  • Rolling out new handheld ordering tablets in all restaurants. Early tests of these tablets last year indicated improvements in order times, greater incident rates, and higher guest satisfaction ratings.
  • Started testing third-party delivery services using BJ's existing mobile app and online ordering systems. Off-premise sales already represented 5% of total revenue in fiscal 2016, compared to a 10% average for the broader industry.
  • Plans to expand daily "brewhouse" specials to showcase its several of the most popular signature menu items at more compelling price points.
  • Installation of new slow roasting ovens in all restaurants by May, with the aim of strengthening and diversifying its menu offerings and value proposition.

BJ's also stated it has a "deep pipeline" of new menu items, recently enhanced its loyalty program, and will implement additional productivity initiatives throughout 2017.

"Taken together," added BJ's Restaurants CEO Greg Trojan, "we believe this to be one of our strongest-ever sales initiative plans."

On imitation and flattery

But as I hinted earlier -- and for better or worse -- BJ's Restaurants' plan isn't exactly unique.

It was almost exactly three years ago, for example, when Buffalo Wild Wings first announced it would roll out tabletop tablets at each of its more than 1,000 North American locations (a number that has grown to more than 1,200 worldwide). Around the same time, Buffalo Wild Wings began early tests of its own mobile ordering and payment solutions.

What's more, Buffalo Wild Wings already started testing delivery servicefor select locations last summer, a move management noted was made after an analyst survey revealed the chain ranked as one of the top companies from which consumers wanted food delivered.

More recently, last quarter Buffalo Wild Wings also implemented a major refresh of its own mobile app, giving loyal customers the ability to save past orders and menu favorites, as well as to receive offers tailored to their personal preferences. Online ordering also grew to 19% of Buffalo Wild Wings' takeout orders at company-owned restaurants in the fourth quarter, up from 12% in the same year-ago period. And speaking of loyalty, Buffalo Wild Wings' new Blazin' rewards program has already been rolled out in 25% of all U.S. locations, and typically results in a 2% boost to same-store sales following its initial rollout.

Meanwhile, Buffalo Wild Wings' menu innovation efforts have already begun to yield fruit by diversifying its offerings away from its namesake menu item, including a new "hand-smashed" burger platform that has increased burger sales by 25% since its launch last October. On top of that, Buffalo Wild Wings has seen strong initial boosts to traffic from value-oriented promotions like FastBreak lunch and Half-Price Wing Tuesdays, both of which were introduced in the middle of last year.

If you can't beat 'em...

To be fair, Buffalo Wild Wings is still coming off four straight quarters of negative same-store despite its intensive efforts to innovate and diversify its dining experience, which goes to show just how difficult it is to navigate today's restaurant business environment. Nonetheless, Buffalo Wild Wings insists the collective contributions of these programs will yield fruit soon, helping it return to positive same-store sales growth by the end of 2017.

That also raises the question: Is BJ's Restaurants consciously following Buffalo Wild Wings' proven blueprint for success? And perhaps more important, will that blueprint be as effective when consumers have already seen it executed in a significantly larger, arguably more popular nationwide restaurant concept?

For now, investors will need to hurry up and wait for the answers to those questions. But in the meantime, you can be sure I'll be watching closely to measure the success of both BJ's Restaurants and Buffalo Wild Wings going forward.

10 stocks we like better than Buffalo Wild WingsWhen investing geniuses David and Tom Gardner have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*

David and Tom just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now... and Buffalo Wild Wings wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.

Click here to learn about these picks!

*Stock Advisor returns as of February 6, 2017

Steve Symington owns shares of Buffalo Wild Wings. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Buffalo Wild Wings. The Motley Fool recommends BJ's Restaurants. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.