Better Buy: HP Inc. or Xerox Corp?

By Leo

At first glance, HP (NYSE: HPQ) and Xerox (NYSE: XRX) look like dusty old tech stocks that are owned for income instead of growth. But on closer inspection, both companies' core businesses are changing substantially due to recent developments. Let's discuss these changes, and see if they're making one of these companies a better long-term investment than the other.

Continue Reading Below

An HP printer (L) and a Xerox photocopier (R). Image source: Company websites.

How are HP and Xerox changing?

Hewlett-Packard split into two companies last year. Hewlett-Packard Enterprise (NYSE: HPE) retained the enterprise hardware and software businesses, while HP (NYSE: HPQ) kept selling computers, printers, and imaging devices. Those businesses are all slow growth, but thecompany hopes that its expansion into high-end 3D printers can revive its top-line growth. HP also recently agreed tobuy Samsung's printing business for $1.05 billion to scale up its operations.

More From

Xerox plans to spin off its business-processing outsourcing operations as a new company called Conduent by the endof the year. Xerox will retain its document and services business, which competes against HP's imaging businesses. Xerox was expected to merge its document and services business with print and publishing company R.R. Donnelleyearlier this year, but it rejected thatdeal in July.

HP's strengths and weaknesses

No one is expecting much growth from HP. Its revenueis expected to fall 7% this year and another 4% next year. It's unclear how much revenue the Samsung acquisition will add to HP's top line because the unit's sales figures haven't been disclosed.

Both of HP's main target markets are wobbly. Last quarter, personal systems (PC)sales fell 13% annually as printing revenues plunged 17%. But HP's earnings from continuing operations, boosted heavily by layoffs andbuybacks, still rose 20% during that quarter.

Gartnerrecently reported thatworldwide PC shipments fell annually for the eighth straight quarter. But between the third quarters of 2015 and 2016, HP's market share in PCs rose from 18.8% to 20.4%, putting it in second place after market leaderLenovo.

HP is the biggest maker of printers in the world, but its market share fell from 40.8% to 36.6% between the second quarters of 2015 and 2016, according toIDC, as rivals Canon and Epson both grew their shares. That market is still shrinking -- IDC reports that worldwide hardcopy peripheral sales fell nearly 4% annually inthe second quarter. On the bright side, sales of large format and3D printers have been improving.

Xerox's strengths and weaknesses

Xerox's Document Technology revenue fell 7% annually last quarter, and Services revenue fell 2%. Analysts expect Xerox's total revenue (not accounting for theConduent split) to fall 3% this year and another 1% next year. The businesses that make up Conduent generated $7 billion, or 39% of Xerox's revenue last year.

While Xerox's top-line growth looks weak, manyinvestors, including Carl Icahn, believe that the Conduent spinoff will strengthen both companies' earnings by streamlining their businesses and cutting costs across theboard. Xerox already cut thousands of jobs earlier this year ahead of the spinoff. Those cuts, along with big buybacks, are expected to boost Xerox's full-year earnings by 15% this year.

Like HP, Xerox's top line will likely benefit from higher demand for large-format printers. The company also announced that it would expand its presence in the 3D printing market inMay.

Growth, valuations, and dividends

Analysts expect HP's annual earnings to grow at an average rate ofjust 2% over the next five years. That gives it a five-year PEG ratio of just 4.8. Because a PEG ratio under 1 is considered undervalued, HP isn't cheap relative to its earnings growth potential.

Xerox's earnings, excluding the impact of the Conduent spinoff, areexpected to rise 3% per year during that same period -- which gives it a lower PEG ratio of 3. However, investors looking for businesses with fewer moving parts should wait until after the spinoff concludes to determine which half of Xerox is a better long-term play.

HP pays a forward yield of 3.2%, which iseasily supported by its payout ratio of 22%. Xerox pays a 3.1% yield, but its payout ratio is a much higher74%. Once again, income investors should wait for the split to see which half ends up with a higher yield. If Xerox follows HP's example (giving the "higher growth" HPE a lower dividend than the "slower growth" HP), Xerox should pay a much higher dividend than Conduent.

So which stock is the better buy?

I'm not bullish on either stock right now, but HP seems to be a better buy. HP is gaining economies of scale by acquiring Samsung's printing business, its PC sales could recover as enterprise demand returns, and it pays a higher dividend with a lower payout ratio. Xerox, however, is tough to recommend until it spins off Conduent, and offers investors a clearer picture of both companies' futures.

A secret billion-dollar stock opportunity The world's biggest tech company forgot to show you something, but a few Wall Street analysts and the Fool didn't miss a beat: There's a small company that's powering their brand-new gadgets and the coming revolution in technology. And we think its stock price has nearly unlimited room to run for early in-the-know investors! To be one of them, just click here.

Leo Sun has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Gartner. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.