Fed Survey: Recession Shrank Card Debt, Crushed Household Wealth


The majority of consumers responded to the recession by shedding cards and paying off their credit card debt, according to data released Monday by the Federal Reserve.

The number of families carrying a balance on their credit cards fell substantially between 2007 and 2010, according to the 2010 Survey of Consumer Finances, a triennial look at Americans' income, net worth and debt. The Fed's 2007 report was published in 2009; data from 2010 was released Monday. According to the survey, 39.4% of families said they had at least one credit card with a balance on it, down 6.7% from 2007.

"The decreased prevalence of credit card debt outstanding was widespread and noticeable across most of the demographic groups," said the Federal Reserve. However, not all groups shed their reliance on credit cards. According to the survey, families headed by someone age 75 or older were more likely to carry credit card debt in 2010 than in 2007. Meanwhile, families headed by someone without a high school diploma also relied on credit cards more heavily after the recession.

Post-recession snapshot

Based on 6,492 interviews with U.S. consumers, the Fed's Survey of Consumer Finances is among the most widely accepted, accurate snapshots available of Americans' finances. The survey is only released every three years. As a result, this is the first in-depth survey Fed survey that looks at how Americans have used credit since the Great Recession struck in mid-2007.

The survey also shed light on just how devastating the recession was to households' balance sheets. American household's median net worth fell a whopping 38.8% between 2007 and 2010, according to the survey, thanks largely to the collapse in value of many people's homes. Meanwhile, median incomes fell for most consumers, with the steepest drops in income sustained by highly educated families, families headed by someone younger than 55 and families living in the South and the West.

"Families' finances are affected by both their own decisions and the state of the broader economy," the report stated. "Over the 2007-2010 period, the U.S. economy experienced its most substantial downturn since the Great Depression."

Credit card debt fell sharply

After the recession, consumers significantly changed how they used their credit cards, according to the survey. For example:

  • A significant number of consumers stopped carrying a balance on their credit cards. This behavior was most pronounced among consumers with middle and high incomes and among educated consumers middle-aged or younger.
  • Credit card debt fell. Among households carrying credit card debt, the median amount dropped 16.1%, from $3,000 to $2,600. The mean amount slipped 7.8%, from $7,300 to $7,100. The term median signifies half were above the number, half below. The mean is the mathematical average. When the mean and median are significantly different, it's because the data points aren't clustered in the middle. In other words, there are a lot of people who owe a lot of money on their credit cards, skewing the average high.
  • The number of cards that families held also dropped. For example, 32.7%of families held four or more cards in 2010, compared to 35% of families in 2007. Fewer families also reported holding three or more cards and a fraction even stopped carrying two or more cards. Approximately .5% dropped their cards completely.
  • The number of people with store and gasoline credit cards dropped substantially as well. However, the number of people carrying charge cards for travel or entertainment purposes -- which don't allow you to carry a balance -- increased.

The survey also breaks down the way people from different walks of life use credit. For example, those who borrowed less on their cards following the recession included families with higher incomes, single families, families without children and families headed by someone working in a managerial, professional, technical or sales-type jobs. Those that continued to rely on cards, in turn, were more likely to be single families with children and families in the lowest income bracket.

Families in the South,  the Midwest and large metropolitan areas were more likely to carry debt. Families in the Northeast were the least likely.

College-educated families are more likely to carry debt than people with just a high school diploma or who dropped out of high school. However, high school dropouts became more likely to carry debt after the recession than before 2007.

Similarly, retirees are less likely to carry debt than other consumers. However, significantly more people of retirement age carried a balance in 2010 than they did in 2007.

The next survey of consumer finances will be released in 2015 and will look at how Americans' finances have fared between 2010 and 2013.