Image source: Netflix.
Continue Reading Below
A permabear when it comes toNetflixisn't changing his tune. Wedbush Securities analyst Michael Pachter kicked off the week by reiterating his bearish "underperform" rating on the stock. His price target of $45 suggests that the leading provider of premium streaming content could lose more than half of its value. The stock closed Monday at $94.67.
Netflix announces fresh financials following next Monday's close. Pachter wants to make sure that his negative opinion of the investment is clear ahead of that second-quarter report.He is reiterating his stance because he feels that Netflix's guidance for the third quarter will be weak. It was weak subscriber guidance for the second quarter issued last time out that weighed on the stock, which dropped 13% the day after the report.
Pachter is also concerned about the competitive climate. Netflix is the undisputed leader in this niche, but rivals aren't exactly asleep at the wheel. He sees Amazon.com as a looming threat, especially now that it's offering its Prime Video catalog as a stand-alone offering to folks that don't want annual subscriptions to Amazon Prime. Amazon charges $8.99 per month for just video access while Netflix charges $9.99 a month.
Holding bulls and bears accountable
Netflix stock dipped on this recent bearish note, but the mere 2% decline shows that the market doesn't seem to be taking the $45 price target seriously. The stock would still have to swan dive another 52% to get there.
Continue Reading Below
It also helps the bullish argument to know that Pachter has been on the wrong end of this argument before. He had a sell rating on the stock and a split-adjusted price target of $7.86 in early 2013. That didn't work out too well. Netflix went on to become the S&P 500's biggest gainer that year, a feat it went on to repeat in 2015.
This doesn't mean that a Netflix bear is always wrong. The stock was crushed in 2011. It lost ground in 2014. It's in the red so far in 2016. However, over the long haul it's the bulls that have had the last laugh.
Let's talk about the real Amazon threat
Amazon offers a pretty sweet value proposition. If you're already a Prime customer ($99 a year or $10.99 per month) relying on the leading online retailer, you get a growing digital catalog of video content at no additional cost. This library was pretty weak a few years ago, but Amazon now has a decent arsenal complete with popular shows and movies as well as some Emmy-winning original content.
This isn't enough to rattle Netflix. Despite the estimated tens of millions of Prime members with essentially no-cost access to Prime Video, it's still an afterthought for consumers when they want to stream TV. Netflix commands 35% of traffic on North America fixed networks, according to broadband network solutions provider Sandvine's latest survey. Amazon Video has gained ground on weaker players lately, but it's drawing just 4.3% of fixed traffic.
Amazon may have turned heads by offering Prime Video as a separate service from Amazon Prime in April, but at $8.99 a month it's actually more than the annual rate of Amazon Prime -- which includes Prime Video -- over the course of the year.
The real game changer in Prime Video is that Amazon also lets folks pay for purchases or digital rentals of new movies and TV shows, something that Netflix has been reluctant to offer. The more people it hooks with Prime Video, the easier it will be to sell them online video rentals and purchases down the line. That's when Amazon could get scary, but for now it's clearly not getting in the way of Netflix's ability to grow.
Pachter isn't alone in being concerned ahead of next week's earnings report. A pair of analysts downgraded the stock last week. Netflix doesn't hit it out of the park every quarter, and there are enough Wall Street pros cooling on the stock to make bulls worry. However, it's hard to argue with Netflix's long-term track record. The best S&P 500 performer in two of the past three years still deserves the market's respect.
The article Netflix Stock's Next Stop Won't Be $45 originally appeared on Fool.com.
Rick Munarriz owns shares of Netflix. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Amazon.com and Netflix. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright 1995 - 2016 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.