Why American Apparel Inc.'s Dov Charney Isn't the Next Michael Dell or Steve Jobs

By Markets Fool.com

Continue Reading Below

The once and future CEO? Dov Charney was fired from American Apparel, but he's trying to engineer a return to his company. Just like Steve Jobs, right? Maybe not. Photo: dovcharney via Flickr.

Quirky clothing retailer American Apparel just fired former CEO Dov Charney. But rumor has it he's trying to buy back the company he founded.

This situation might look similar to instanced in which other CEOs stepped aside or were pushed out only to return later on to save the business they created, but that's where any similarities end.

True visionaries
Michael Dell stepped down as CEO of Dell only to return several years later as the company struggled to navigate a changing landscape in PCs. He ultimately took Dell private to keep it out of the public eye as he reorganized the turnaround.

Similarly, Steve Jobs was fired from Apple in 1985 only to triumphantly return 12 years later at the request of the board to lead the faltering tech giant forward to an incredible resurrection.

Continue Reading Below

But when it comes to American Apparel, this companyis no Dell computer and Charney is no Steve Jobs.

The retailer is an idiosyncratic mix of blind loyalty and crass opportunism blending prurient advertising and Made-in-the-USA manufacturing. Some say the dichotomy is emblematic of Charney himself, and that American Apparel will wither and die without his leadership.

Of course, with Charney still on board, the retailer is a combustible cocktail of liability waiting to happen. In either case, American Apparel is a troubled investment and difficult to recommend.

Dov Charney is the face of American Apparel, but that might not be such a good thing for shareholders who've seen their investment rocked by his antics. Photo: dovcharney via Flickr.

Summer of discontent
The retailer lurched into turmoil this summer when the board of directors abruptly fired Charney for undisclosed allegations of willful misconduct. Considering that this followed years of such allegations (and a few settlements), it was left to the imagination as to what new evidence the board uncovered.

Yet Charney partnered with hedge fund Standard General to manuever a takeover of the board, leading to a stay of the dimissal until a complete investigation was conducted. Charney was kept on in a creative role and an interim CEO was appointed.

That ended last week when the board -- consisting of members appointed by the hedge fund -- fired Charney again for misconduct, including sexual harassment and misuse of corporate funds.

But the board created a new controversy by appointing a new CEO, Paula Schneider, without taking into consideration the opinions of the company's managers. A group of 30 managers loyal to Charney who wanted him to continue in some capacity at the retailer asked the board in writing to reconsider its decision.

Now it's a buyout candidate
Now American Apparel is reportedly the target of several buyout bids, including onesupposedly from Charney himself with backing from Irving Place Capital that is willing to pay up to $1.40 per share for the company. Charney still owns 43% of the retailer's stock, though Standard General controls the shares as collateral on its original loan to Charney.

If successful, it would mark yet another strange turn in a tale full of odd chapters, but in response to the bidsthe board also adopted a shareholder rights plan that prevents anyone from accumulating more than 10% of American Apparel's stock. The board said it is not blocking any acquisition attempts, but rather it wants to be able to review them without pressure.

Yet in a sign of the upheaval still evident at the retailer, the company on Monday said its two board co-chairmen stepped down and would be replaced by Colleen Brown, one of Standard General's appointed directors.

Playing a dangerous game
All of which makes American Apparel a chaotic mess. Its stock might have rocketed higher on the takeover news, but there's too much uncertainty surrounding the company and so much risk if Charney returns.

This isn't anything like Michael Dell or Steve Jobs returning to save their companies. Their return didn't set the stage for even greater turmoil, but rather for a period of calm.

American Apparel is more like a game of Russian roulette with its former CEO spinning the barrel and leaving investors wondering when the next shot will go off.

The article Why American Apparel Inc.'s Dov Charney Isn't the Next Michael Dell or Steve Jobs originally appeared on Fool.com.

Follow Rich Duprey's coverage of all the retailing industry's most important news and developments. Hehas no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Apple. The Motley Fool owns shares of Apple. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.