In reply to leagues' attempt to stop sports betting, New Jersey cites appellate court ruling

Industries Associated Press

Claims that New Jersey's plan to allow legal sports gambling violates federal law are meritless, the state wrote in a court filing in response to efforts by four major U.S. pro sports leagues and the NCAA to stop gambling from beginning this weekend.

Continue Reading Below

The state filed the response late Wednesday to the leagues' request to a federal judge this week for an injunction to prevent Monmouth Park racetrack from accepting sports wagers this Sunday. The track is the only venue in the state that has said it will take bets under a law signed by Gov. Chris Christie last Friday that allows sports betting at racetracks and casinos.

The NFL, the NBA, the NHL, Major League Baseball and the NCAA have until the end of Thursday to file a reply to the state's filing, after which U.S. District Michael Shipp has indicated he will decide whether oral argument is necessary. It isn't known when he will make a decision.

In its filing, the state reiterated its contention that the language in a federal appeals court ruling last year opened the door for New Jersey to roll back its prohibitions on sports gambling and legally allow it as long as it isn't regulated by the state.

The leagues contend that it will, in fact, be state-regulated because racetracks and casinos are heavily regulated by the state and that this constitutes state-authorized sports betting — which is prohibited by a 1992 federal law. They also claim they will suffer "irreparable harm" if sports gambling is allowed in New Jersey.

New Jersey charged the leagues with seeking to have the federal government interfere in state affairs.

Continue Reading Below

"Plaintiffs' claims that their multi-billion-dollar businesses will suffer irreparable damage from even short-term wagering at Monmouth Park — when similar wagering has taken place throughout the State of Nevada for more than fifty years, and to a much greater extent — are unsubstantiated and cannot be credited," the brief states.

Only Nevada currently offers single-game sports betting. Delaware and two other states are allowed to offer multi-game sports parlay pools.

Christie signed a sports wagering bill in early 2012 and the leagues sued later that year. The state's constitutional challenge to the 1992 federal law failed, but in September Christie ordered authorities not to prosecute racetracks and casinos for accepting sports bets, and signed amended legislation reflecting that last week.