This 6-bedroom, 10-bath home at 3600 Nelsons Walk is on the market for $18.9 million in Naples, FL.

This 6-bedroom, 10-bath home at 3600 Nelsons Walk is on the market for $18.9 million in Naples, FL. (Zillow)

The Most Expensive Streets in America

By Home Mortgage Zillow

No helicopters, no mega yachts. At first glance, Indian Creek is just a small private island in Biscayne Bay. But South Florida real estate agent Cory Waldman begs to differ.

Continue Reading Below

“It’s a city within a city,” the Coldwell Banker associate said. “They have their own police force. The lot sizes are enormous. It’s top-notch.”

Across the country, luxury real estate agent Kofi Natei Nartey has a similar reaction — but not about Indian Creek.

“Beverly Park is the most exclusive gated community in Los Angeles,” The Agency‘s Sports & Entertainment Division director said. “With guard-gated access only, it attracts some of the highest net worth individuals and celebrities in the world.”

They’re not exaggerating. New data shows Indian Creek Island Road and Beverly Park Circle are the most expensive streets to live on in the U.S.

Indian Creek, known locally as Billionaire Bunker, is home to four of the richest people in America, the Miami Herald reports. Beverly Park Circle is home to Denzel Washington and Eddie Murphy, among other big names.

Continue Reading Below

So what does it cost to live there? Based on Zillow’s analysis of streets with at least 10 homes, here’s a look at the median home value for the top 15:

Rank

Street

State

Median Home Value

1. Indian Creek Island Rd FL $21.48 million
2. Beverly Park Cir CA $16.238 million
3. Beverly Park Ter CA $15.813 million
4. Lazy Lane Blvd TX $15.42 million
5. Conyers Farm Dr CT $13.033 million
6. Strawberry Park Ct CO $12.421 million
7. Field Point Cir CT $12.113 million
8. Coopers Neck Ln NY $11.872 million
9. Nimes Rd CA $11.445 million
10. Arvida Pkwy FL $11.209 million
11. Cameldale Way AZ $10.834 million
12. Nelsons Walk FL $10.496 million
13. Broad Beach Rd CA $10.272 million
14. Tahiti Beach Island Rd FL $10.267 million
15. Copa De Oro Rd CA $10.264 million

 

Names vs. numbers

Interestingly, all of the priciest streets are names, rather than numbers. In “Zillow Talk: The New Rules of Real Estate,” co-authors Spencer Rascoff and Stan Humphries explore what’s in a street name. By digging into the data, they’ve found a named-street premium exists across the country.

Among the 20 largest metro areas, “we only found three places in the entire nation where named streets don’t have the advantage,” they write. “In Atlanta and New York, named and numbered streets come out roughly equal. Denver is the solitary example of a place where numbered streets are more valuable — probably because homes in its premier neighborhood of Country Club are located on numbered streets.”

What gives named streets a higher price tag? Rascoff and Humphries say in general, the most valuable street names describe something about a home’s location. Indian Creek Island Road is a great example because “island” indicates the homes are near water, and therefore probably worth more than non-waterfront homes in the area.

Suffixes matter

It’s easy to gloss over the letters tacked on at the end of a street name. But as shown above, living on Beverly Park Terrace versus Beverly Park Circle could cost you hundreds of thousands of dollars.

In their analysis, Rascoff and Humphries discovered the most common suffixes — street, boulevard and avenue — tend to be the least valuable. Way and place, meanwhile, make up only 4 percent of street name suffixes nationwide, and their homes’ are typically worth more.

These findings shed light on the myriad factors at play in local real estate markets. Of course, at the end of the day, lot comes down to perception.

“There’s nothing else like [Indian Creek] in South Florida,” Waldman said. “It’s the most prestigious address.”

More from Zillow.com
Markets Where Starbucks Boosts Home Values the Most
The Real Estate Obsession Grows … to IMAX Proportions
The Most Expensive Home for Sale in Every State

Catherine Sherman, a real estate writer for Zillow Blog, covers real estate news, industry trends and home design.