Senate Kills Competing Spending Cut Bills

Politics Reuters

The Senate defeated a pair of spending-cut bills on Wednesday -- a Republican plan for nearly $60 billion in reductions and a far smaller Democratic alternative -- increasing pressure on both sides to cut a bipartisan deal.

Continue Reading Below

The two votes were staged by congressional leaders as a way of demonstrating that both parties need to compromise on spending and deficit-reduction for the rest of this fiscal year, which ends on September 30.

"Our goal is to fund the government the rest of this year and in outyears. This isn't just the next few weeks (of funding). We're going to try to get a universal deal," Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid told reporters after the votes.

The White House said in a statement that the Senate votes showed Republicans and Democrats "must come together to find common ground" on the budget.

With public opinion polls ambivalent over the call for deep spending cuts, the next steps were unclear.
A Reuters/Ipsos poll on Wednesday found 51% of Americans want to see defense spending cut, with much weaker support for cutting government retirement and health programs. Only 45% thought the Republican proposals to deeply cut domestic, non-defense programs were "essential" to balancing the budget.

Republicans emboldened by congressional election wins last year are at loggerheads with President Barack Obama's Democrats over how to reduce the budget deficit, due to hit a record $1.65 trillion this year.

Continue Reading Below

Spurred on by Tea Party fiscal conservatives, Republicans want steep spending cuts for this year, but Obama has warned that too much belt tightening will hurt economic recovery.

Obama met on Wednesday with a group of Democratic senators and Vice President Joe Biden called Republican House of Representatives Speaker John Boehner and Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell.

"The president and vice president urged them to come together to find a solution that funds the government through the end of the fiscal year and reiterated their commitment to helping make this happen," White House spokesman Jay Carney said in a statement.

Negotiators face a March 18 deadline, when current funding for government programs expires. Lacking the time to work out a bipartisan spending deal for the remainder of the year, Congress is expected to pass a sixth stop-gap funding bill to avert a government shutdown.

The House could unveil its newest temporary spending bill as soon as Friday and pass it early next week, a source said.

On a mostly partisan vote of 56-44, the Democratic-controlled Senate rejected the House Republicans' measure, which also would have stopped Obama's healthcare reform law from being implemented.

Then the Democratic alternative to trim $4.7 billion from current spending fared even worse when it was defeated by a vote of 58-42.

Senator Charles Schumer called the Republicans' plan a "scorched earth spending proposal that counts among the casualties such critical priorities as border security, cancer research and food safety inspectors."

GETTING SERIOUS

But the two Senate votes, Schumer predicted, will be a "breakthrough" as they make clear that "both parties' opening bids ... are non-starters" and "we can finally get serious about sitting down and narrowing the huge gap that exists."

Washington's intense interest in the budget is prompted by successive years of record deficits topped by an estimated $1.65 trillion in red ink just for this fiscal year, which ends September 30. That deficit would be equal to 10.9% of the U.S. economy.

This has led to fears of an eventual meltdown of the world's largest economy as total debt, now at $14.2 trillion, is piling up to a level that economists warn is unsustainable.

Tackling government spending comes as the Obama administration is trying to steer the U.S. economy onto a path of sound economic growth after the 2007-2009 recession.

Democrats warn that cutting domestic spending too deeply too soon will jeopardize the recovery and kill jobs. But conservatives are insisting on accelerating spending cuts.

Republican Senator Rand Paul, a Tea Party favorite, said the two spending-cut options killed by the Senate were "inadequate and do not significantly alter ... our course."

He has called for spending cuts near $500 billion, urged the shuttering of entire Cabinet offices such as the Education Department and sought to send the federal Medicare healthcare program for the elderly "back to the states."

On Wednesday, both the liberal Schumer and the conservative Paul spoke of cutting U.S. defense spending, now hovering at $700 billion a year, or about one-fifth of the entire budget
Schumer, in a speech to the Center for American Progress think tank, proposed targeting not just defense spending but also programs with powerful constituencies -- farm subsidies and the Medicare and Medicaid health programs -- along with hundreds of billions of dollars in duplicative programs.

What do you think?

Click the button below to comment on this article.