Oil traders and analysts have traced the market's recovery to signs of tighter supply and a return of geopolitical tensions.
Continue Reading Below
But many are also pointing to rising confidence that U.S. shale producers won't endlessly ramp up production.
For the past three years, earnings reports from shale companies often contributed to lower oil prices, as investors feared an onslaught of output from wells would hit an already bloated market.
Now, guidance from producers in Texas and North Dakota is helping lift oil prices out of a trading range. Investors hope that companies will be more disciplined about pumping for massive volumes of oil, removing an overhang that has consistently weighed on prices in recent years.
From mid-2014 through August, oil has tumbled by an average of 2.2% during earnings periods when U.S. producers touted the ability to slash costs and deploy new technologies to produce more crude, data from Barclays PLC and The Wall Street Journal show. But in the most recent earnings season, oil prices rose more than 4%, data compiled by the Journal show.
Companies are saying, "even if we get some upside in the commodity, we're not going to plow that into the ground -- we're going to remain disciplined." said Gordon Douthat, an analyst at Wells Fargo.
Continue Reading Below
Oil-market participants like the sound of that. A growing chorus of investors are pushing shale companies to rein in spending, and rising costs have made it harder for these companies to ramp up quickly.
Marathon Oil Corp., for example, told investors this month that it is making plans for next year based on oil prices of about $50. Even if prices rise and the company finds itself with extra cash, quick boosts to output won't be on the top of the to-do list, the company said.
"It's going to come back to those high-level priorities, starting with making sure that we protect and support an investment-grade balance sheet through continued gross debt reduction," Chief Executive Lee Tillman said on a call with analysts.
If the producers take a more disciplined approach, they will be less likely to react to short-term price increases, said Christopher Burton, senior portfolio manager at Credit Suisse Asset Management.
Oil prices had their biggest one-day tumble in over a month Tuesday, falling 1.87% to $55.70 a barrel as the International Energy Agency revised its demand forecast downward.
There are already indications that shale production isn't as buoyant as some had expected. The number of rigs drilling for oil has plateaued -- it stood at 738 rigs as of Friday, 30 fewer than in August.
And rising costs could result in a more measured pace of growth. Services companies like Halliburton Co. and Schlumberger Ltd. are raising prices. Bottlenecks in availability of labor and equipment are emerging.
Some investors say shale producers won't be able to fully take advantage of oil's rise. Producers use longer-term contracts to lock in prices, and those prices aren't rising as quickly as near-term prices -- a market condition that often arises when supplies tighten.
"It limits the hedging opportunity," said Terence Brennan, a portfolio manager at Lazard Asset Management.
To be sure, shale companies are pumping more oil.
Even those companies that say they will rein in spending are still projecting that production levels will rise. Parsley Energy, one of the most prolific Permian drillers, has said it is planning a "more measured development pace" next year and isn't putting more rigs to work in the next six to eight months. Still, it anticipates that its output will grow by as much as 50% in 2018.
Goldman Sachs analysts expect U.S. output will grow by 800,000 to 900,000 barrels a day if oil prices average $55 next year, noting that companies are becoming more efficient -- producing more oil with less spending -- and services costs haven't gone up enough to slow down drilling. Perhaps most important, capital markets are still open to these companies.
But others say that even if shale producers keep pumping, it won't be enough of it to knock the oil market from its bullish perch.
A group of 18 U.S. exploration and production companies reported output about 1% higher than the end of last year, according to Morgan Stanley -- "hardly the runaway growth that overwhelms the oil market," the analysts noted.
And most companies have said they plan to keep capital spending within operating cash flow, a target that will be hard to hit unless oil prices rise significantly.
"If these intentions indeed stick, it will weigh on production growth in 2018," the Morgan Stanley analysts said.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
November 15, 2017 07:14 ET (12:14 GMT)