Home / Markets
Friday, May 01, 2009
Up and Coming
Employment in Focus as Busy Week Comes to a Close
By Mark Lieberman, Senior Economist
FOXBusiness

As almost a throw-away line during his news conference Wednesday, President Obama said the stimulus package he signed into
law on February 17 had saved or created 100,000 to 150,000 jobs.
“The estimate,” according to an Administration official, “does not mean that employment has risen by 150,000. Rather, it means
that employment is 150,000 higher than it otherwise would have been.”
The President’s comment is not insignificant as we come into a week which will be capped with the release of the Employment
Situation report on the April labor market – a report expected to show the economy coughed up another 630,000 jobs and the
number of people working fell again.
[Where the explanation of the President’s comment is confusing is that it mixes jobs and employment, a common error. The jobs
tally comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ “establishment survey” which tracks the number of jobs; employment comes
from the “household survey” which tracks the number of people working. Those numbers can be different: if a person has two
jobs, that individual shows up twice in the establishment survey but once in the household survey. Taken another way, if one
of the jobs is eliminated, the jobs tally goes down, but employment does not.]
In coming up with the 100,000-150,000 figure, the Administration official said, “We estimated the effect of the American Recovery
and Reinvestment Act (“ARRA”) on employment as of April 29, 2009 in two ways. One was to prorate the original quarterly estimates
of the effect of the ARRA prepared by the Council of Economic Advisors (“CEA”) at the time of passage in a conservative way.
The second was to use the data available on actual spending as of April 21, 2009 to replace the assumed spend-out rate. We
then applied the same estimates of the likely impact of spending on output and employment used in the original calculations.
Both methods yield similar results (suggesting that our original spending assumptions were reasonably accurate).
Since the initial CEA estimates were based on robust assumptions, the new numbers offered by the President might be described
as an estimate to the second degree.
The one certainty the Administration has is how much of the $787 billion ARRA was actually spent – that is disbursed. It can’t
though track how the money was used, whether to buy goods and services or hire. Even money distributed for specific projects
doesn’t guarantee hiring since if a city or county starts work on a project, it doesn’t hire every worker immediately.
The tally will come in Friday and except for some number-crunchers, the specifics won’t matter. Instead economists will be
looking at trends, the same trends that lead some to believe the economy has bottomed.
One of the “green shoots” is that the advance Gross Domestic Product report for the first quarter showed the economy contracted
at a 6.1% annualized rate, not the 5.0% contraction expected, but also not much different than the 6.3% decline in the fourth
quarter. So while the economy didn’t improve, it didn’t get worse. There were some indicators within the GDP to suggest an
uptick: a lot of the decline was due to a harsh reduction in inventory. To the extent consumers resume spending, those inventories
would have to be replenished. The concern with that argument is the heavy consumer spending on services which don’t require
the same level of inventory re-build.
Government spending was also surprisingly weak in the first quarter and will increase in the second.
Consumers remain the challenge for economy and Friday’s report could provide a clue as to their future direction. The employment
report will include data on average hourly earnings, hours worked and the number of people employed. Earnings and employment
have been dropping (and hours worked fell in March to a record low). Multiplying all three elements, aggregate earnings dropped
0.7% in March but more significantly is down 2.1% since March 2008, the third month in a row of year-year decline. January
2008 was the first time aggregate earnings had dropped year-year since all the data elements were compiled.
Mark Lieberman is the senior economist for the Fox Business Network. Prior to joining FOX, he served as first vice president and manager of economic analysis and research at Washington Mutual in New York. Before that, he served as senior vice president at Dime Savings Bank of New York (which was later acquired by Washington Mutual), where he specialized in credit and risk management. He is a member of the Executive Committee of the New York Association for Business Economics. He has a degree in Economics from the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.
| MONDAY | May 04 | CONSTRUCTION SPENDING (Mar) |
| February actual: DOWN 0.9% | ||
| March consensus: DOWN 1.3% | ||
| PENDING HOME SALES INDEX (Mar) | ||
| February actual: 82.1, UP 1.7 | ||
| March Consensus 81.8 | ||
| FEDERAL RESERVE SENIOR LOAN OFFICER SURVEY (2Q) | ||
| (Due this week) | ||
| Kansas City Fed President Thomas Hoenig speaks on the financial crisis | ||
| TUESDAY | May 05 | ISM NON-MANUFACTURING INDEX (Apr) |
| March actual: 40.8, UP 0.5 | ||
| April consensus: 42.0 | ||
| Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke testifies before the Joint Economic Committee on the Economic Outlook | ||
| Federal Reserve Chairman Bernanke speaks at weekly Republican luncheon | ||
| San Francisco Fed President Janet Yellen speaks on the recession | ||
| WEDNESDAY | May 06 | MBA APPLICATION INDEX (Week ended: May 1) |
| Total Index | ||
| Week Ended April 24: 960.6 DOWN 18.1% | ||
| Four-week moving average: 1,170.9, DOWN 0.8% | ||
| Purchase Index: | ||
| Week Ended April 24: 251.6, DOWN 0.6% | ||
| Four-week moving average: 269.9, DOWN 1.4% | ||
| Refi Index: | ||
| Week Ended April 24: 5,108.2, DOWN 21.9% | ||
| Four-week moving average: 6,431.9, DOWN 0.6% | ||
| No May 1 consensus | ||
| CHALLENGER LAYOFFS (Apr) | ||
| March actual: 150,411 DOWN 35,939 from Feb | ||
| No April consensus | ||
| ADP EMPLOYMENT REPORT (Apr) | ||
| March actual: DOWN 742,000 | ||
| April consensus: DOWN 645,000 | ||
| THURSDAY | May 07 | UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE CLAIMS (Wk Ended May 2) |
| Initial Claims: | ||
| April 25 Actual: 631,000, DOWN 14,000 | ||
| May 2 Consensus: 635,000 | ||
| Four-week moving average: 637,250, DOWN 10,750 | ||
| No May 2 consensus | ||
| Continuing Claims (Wk ended Apr 25) | ||
| Week Ended Apr 18: 6,271,000, UP 133,000 | ||
| April 25 Consensus: 6,330,000 | ||
| PRODUCTIVITY AND COSTS - Preliminary (1Q) | ||
| Productivity | ||
| 4Q actual: DOWN 0.4 | ||
| 1Q consensus: UP 0.4 | ||
| Unit Labor Costs | ||
| 4Q actual: UP 5.7 | ||
| 1Q consensus: UP 3.1 | ||
| CONSUMER CREDIT (Mar) | ||
| February actual: DOWN $7.48 Billion | ||
| March consensus: DOWN $2.5 Billion | ||
| Chicago Fed President Charles Evans gives welcoming remarks at Bank Structure and Competition conference | ||
| Chairman Ben S. Bernanke speaks (via satellite) at Chicago Fed Conference on Bank Structure and Competition | ||
| FRIDAY | May 08 | EMPLOYMENT SITUATION (Apr) |
| Payroll Employment (M-M Change) | ||
| March actual: DOWN 663,000 | ||
| April consensus | ||
| Unemployment Rate | ||
| March actual: 8.5% (from 8.1%) | ||
| April consensus: | ||
| Average Hourly Earnings | ||
| March actual: $18.50, UP $0.03, 0.2% | ||
| April consensus: | ||
| Average Weekly Hours | ||
| March actual: 33.2 DOWN 0.1 | ||
| April consensus: 33.3 |
Fox Business Video
-
-
Would 'Sin Tax' on Sugary Food...
-
Feb 9, 2010
Michelle Obama launches anti-obesity campaign
-
-
-
Congress Shutdown a Good Thing
-
Feb 9, 2010
House members take week off due to snow
-
-
-
Shaping Up Wall Street
-
Feb 9, 2010
Eric Dinallo on running for NY AG
-
-
-
Tips for John Thain
-
Feb 9, 2010
Some tips for the new CIT CEO
-
-
-
Madison Square Garden Goes Public
-
Feb 9, 2010
MSG splits from Cablevision
-
Last 5 Stocks
- Ticker
- Company
- Price
- Change
