How to Spot Medical Billing Errors.Blame it on human error, the complexity of billing codes, or unscrupulous medical professionals, but one thing is for sure: medical billing mistakes are a common occurrence.
In fact, some estimates claim as many as eight in 10 medical bills issued by hospitals contain an error, costing consumers and insurance providers thousands of dollars every year.
“The errors that are being billed to the health-care payers, whether intentional or unintentional, are increasing due to the complex billing system,” says Pat Palmer, founder of Medical Billing Advocates of America in Roanoke, Va.
Medical billing experts explain hospitals across the nation use one universal billing system to charge patients and insurers. The system doesn’t provide an itemized list of the expenses on a bill, but rather lump sums under particular headings. The lack of an itemized bill makes it easy for mistakes to go unnoticed.
“Insurance companies don’t tend to ask for an itemized statement unless its $10,000 or more,” says Cyndee Weston, executive director of the American Medical Billing Association, in Oklahoma City. She recommends consumers always request an itemized bill. “You won’t know what all those miscellaneous charges are that make up that one fee.”
Your Health Insurance Questions Answered
Medical Bankruptcies are Still a Problem, Here's What to Expect
How Long Does it Take for a Medical Debt to Go to Collections?
Should You Charge a Medical Bill on a Rewards Credit Card?
One Way to Survive Without Health Insurance
Saving on sky-high medical bills
Don’t Pay that Total. How to Negotiate Your Medical Bills
To combat errors, experts recommend combing over itemized bills to spot duplicate or unwarranted charges.
Lisa Zamosky, health reform expert from WebMD, says some of the most common errors include longer stays in the hospital, tests or doctor visits that didn’t occur, or duplicate charges that should be already factored into the price of a hospital room.
According to Palmer, it’s common for a hospital to charge two or three times for the same thing. She says patients entering an operating room are paying anywhere from $60 to $200 a minute depending on the procedure, but that per-minute charge doesn’t only cover the patient, it also covers all the costs to operate the OR.
However, it’s not unusual for a patient to be charged for a surgical kit and tray and then also be wrongfully hit with a separate charge for a knife or other instruments. “First and foremost, any payer should require a detailed itemized statement,” says Palmer. “Everybody is entitled to one…the hospitals don’t voluntarily hand them out.”
Zamosky adds that another way to help spot errors is for patients to review their explanation or benefits of EOB from the insurer. The EOB is a document consumers receive from their insurance provider that explains what was charged to the company and what will be covered.
Zamosky says the EOB should match the doctor’s bills and with what actually happened during the visit. “Check the EOB to make sure you are getting the rate your insurer has negotiated with in-network providers,” she says. “That’s especially important now that more of us have high deductible plans.” If the amount an insurer paid is the same as the amount the plan allows, it’s likely a patient didn’t get the negotiated rate. In that instance, patients should request the insurer reprocess the claim.
Consumers who find mistakes on their bill should call the hospital, doctor and insurance provider right away. If they don’t get anywhere on the phone, put the situation in writing and mail it to all the concerned parties. Most of the time, if an error is an honest mistake, a phone call to the billing department will correct the situation. However, if the situation becomes dragged out and not fixed, it might be time to enlist a health care advocate to dispute the charges,
“You need to investigate those bills regardless of it you have insurance or not,” says Palmer. “Don’t be intimidated. Question the charges.”