High court steps into fight on Vanderbilts' Breakers mansion

Markets Associated Press

FILE - In this Dec. 1, 2014, file photo, visitors walk toward an entrance to The Breakers mansion in Newport, R.I. The battle over the Vanderbilt mansion, The Breakers, goes before the Rhode Island Supreme Court Tuesday, Oct. 25, 2016. The nonprofit ... group that owns the spectacular mansion in Newport is planning to build a visitors center on its grounds. That plan is opposed by dozens of members of the Vanderbilt family and many preservationists, who say it would damage the integrity of the grounds. (AP Photo/Steven Senne, File) (The Associated Press)

Rhode Island's highest court heard arguments Tuesday in a fight that has pitted dozens of members of the Vanderbilt family against a nonprofit that owns several Gilded Age mansions in Newport.

Continue Reading Below

The nonprofit Preservation Society of Newport County wants to build a visitors center on the grounds of The Breakers, a spectacular mansion built by Cornelius Vanderbilt II.

Dozens of preservationists, as well as designer Gloria Vanderbilt and nearly four dozen Vanderbilt relatives, have said the center as planned would "permanently mar" the national historic landmark.

Two members of the Vanderbilt family attended Tuesday's arguments before the Rhode Island Supreme Court over two separate lawsuits. But the arguments involved zoning and licensing issues raised by neighbors and the city, not the family's objections and the question of whether the center would hurt the historical integrity of the site.

The Preservation Society wants to build the center to give visitors a place to buy snacks and sandwiches, use accessible restrooms and buy tickets indoors. They have argued The Breakers is a museum, and museums should be allowed to serve food.

Daniel Prentiss, a lawyer for the neighbors' group, told the Supreme Court that The Breakers is in a residential zone in "one of the most famous neighborhoods in the country." The neighborhood is packed with mansions and bordered on one side by the Atlantic Ocean and Cliff Walk.

Continue Reading Below

Allowing food to be served at The Breakers, Prentiss said, could open the door to museums serving food elsewhere in the neighborhood and city.

But Preservation Society lawyer William Landry said most museums around the world allow patrons to have a glass of wine and a meal, and the Preservation Society would have to meet certain requirements for food service.

"This is no license to have McDonald's in every museum in Newport," Landry told the justices, adding that The Breakers hosts 400,000 people from all over the world every year.

The Breakers, perhaps the grandest of Newport's summer homes, is not air conditioned.

"It's a miserable place to be in July and August," Landry said. "We can't sell an elderly lady a bottle of water?"

Landry said after the arguments that he expects the court to issue a decision within 90 days.