MasterCard's five-year battle to keep multi-billion-euro cross-border card fees was dealt a blow on Thursday when an adviser to Europe's top court backed efforts to reduce such charges.
Continue Reading Below
The legal opinion follows a European Commission ruling that said MasterCard's cross-border "interchange" fees - levied on retailers' credit and debit card transactions - broke antitrust rules and had to be changed.
Mastercard challenged this but the court adviser's recommendation now means it is likely to fail.
The EU antitrust regulator says such fees cost businesses across Europe 10 billion euros ($13.64 billion) a year.
Many consumer rights campaigners argue these hidden costs, charged when banks process payments by, for example, a German visiting London, are passed on to the consumer.
"I propose that the court should dismiss the main appeal (by MasterCard) and the cross-appeals," Advocate General Paolo Mengozzi at the EU Court of Justice said in his opinion.
Continue Reading Below
The court, which will issue its judgement in the coming months, follows such advice in the majority of cases.
The opinion represents a setback to the world's second-largest credit and debit-card company after Visa. Mastercard says such interference would actually lead to higher costs for consumers and encourage the black economy.
The advice may also bolster support for proposed European Union rules to cap charges on card payments that have yet to be approved by EU countries and the bloc's parliament.
That crackdown is part of the Commission's push to boost e-commerce in the 28-country bloc and reduce costs for business.
Interchange fees are collected and kept by banks processing payments using cards. While MasterCard does not benefit directly from the charge, it fears a crackdown will discourage lenders from issuing its cards.
MasterCard, which faces increasing competition from rival payment schemes such as eBay's PayPal, was critical of the decision.
"Practical experience in countries such as Spain, Australia and the United States shows that capping interchange shifts the costs for transactions from retailers on to consumers," MasterCard President Javier Perez said in a statement.
"A one-size-fits all approach to interchange across Europe will drive the cost of cards up for consumers ... and ignores the very different market realities across European countries," he said.
EU retail lobby EuroCommerce, whose 1997 complaint triggered the first regulatory investigation into MasterCard, welcomed the recommendation.
"This should be another reason for the European Parliament to go forward with regulation on interchange fees," said Ruth Milligan of EuroCommerce.
MasterCard has said the value of cross-border card transactions is less than 5 percent of all purchases made by cardholders. A lower court threw out its challenge in 2012.
In the long-running dispute with the European Commission about such charges, MasterCard has made some concessions.
It agreed to reduce its debit card charges to 0.20 percent of a transaction and 0.30 percent for credit cards, pending this court ruling.
Rival Visa Europe, Europe's largest card network and the European licensee of Visa, has offered similar concessions.